Every Maine winter brings the same challenges: deep snow, sudden temperature swings, and relentless wind. It also brings a familiar set of myths that homeowners continue to believe about caring for their homes through the cold months. Unfortunately, those long-standing assumptions can cause real damage and unnecessary costs down the line.

Local roofing contractors in Damariscotta see the same roofing misconceptions resurface each winter, along with the same avoidable problems that follow. Read on to learn the truth behind these myths, how they started, and what steps actually keep your home protected.

What are some myths about roofs and winter?

Each winter, homeowners across Maine get plenty of advice on how to protect their properties from snow, ice, and seasonal damage. While some of those tips are harmless or even helpful, many can do much more harm than good. Below, we’ve highlighted several of the most common misconceptions and the truth behind each.

Myth #1: Debris is usually harmless on the surface

This myth often comes from the belief that a few leaves or pine needles can’t cause trouble once the snow starts falling. But the actual issue is that organic matter can hold moisture. When debris collects in valleys, gutters, or along seams, it traps dampness and slows melting. In freezing weather, that moisture freezes and can then lift materials or clog drainage paths.

Frequent freeze–thaw cycles can make this even worse. Melting during the day, followed by subzero nights, means any trapped water turns into expanding ice that can cause damage. The safest approach to this is always prevention, in this case, through regular roof debris removal and keeping gutters clear before the first snow.

Myth #2: Snow buildup is good for insulation

At first glance, it might make sense to think of snow as an extra layer of insulation that’ll help keep the heat in. In reality, built-up snow is heavy, and the longer it sits, the more stress it puts on the structure. Wet, dense snow can weigh up to 20 pounds per cubic foot. Over time, that kind of snow load on the roof can strain framing or cause leaks.

There’s also the issue of uneven melting. When heat escapes through the attic, it melts the lower layer of snow, which can refreeze at the eaves and form ice dams. Those ridges block runoff and push moisture back under the outer covering. In most cases, this is a sign that you need to improve insulation or ventilation, not that you should rely on snow for warmth.

Myth #3: Metal roofs are loud in rain and snow

This common myth comes from the image of rain clanging against old barn roofs years and decades ago. But when it comes to modern standing-seam systems, are metal roofs loud when it rains? No, not really. Early panels did echo sound, but that was because they rarely had any underlayment or insulation.

Today, each panel is installed over a solid deck with multiple layers below that’ll help mute any noiseIndoors, the difference between metal and any other material is barely noticeable. So, if you’re considering a standing-seam metal system for its strength and long lifespan, you can be confident it’ll be quiet too.

Myth #4: Salt is a good solution for snow on the surface

When ice begins forming along the eaves, it’s tempting to reach for salt. It’s a go-to solution for driveways and walkways, so many assume it’s safe for other surfaces too. In reality, salt is one of the worst choices for exterior finishes. While it melts snow quickly, it also corrodes metal, discolors shingles, and harms nearby landscaping once the runoff drains away.

Plus, salt doesn’t address the cause of icing, it just shifts it around. Instead, it’s best to rely on professionals who use safe mechanical methods or specialized de-icing products. Tools like snow rakes, heated cables, and long-term upgrades to ventilation and insulation are far more effective and won’t risk damaging the structure.

Myth #5: Ice dams only form on older structures

While there’s some difference between materials such as asphalt shingles and standing-seam metal, ice dams don’t discriminate. They can form whenever snow melts unevenly, no matter the age of the home. In fact, newer houses with tight sealing and limited ventilation are often more prone to ice dams during winter due to warm air trapped in attics.

Even a brand-new installation can experience ice dam roof damage if airflow is restricted or gutters can’t handle the runoff. The most effective ice-dam prevention combines proper insulation, balanced ventilation, and well-designed drainage. Together, these elements help keep surface temperature consistent so snow melts evenly across the structure.

Myth #6: You should wait until spring for repairs

This idea likely comes from sound assumptions about materials in cold weather or concerns about technician safety, but in reality, it depends on the situation. Severe conditions can delay non-urgent work, but when it comes to residential roof repair, winter can actually be the right time to act. 

Allowing small leaks, wind damage, or storm-related issues to wait until spring often makes matters worse. That’s why professionals often stay available for emergency roof repairs in the winter. You can count on them to adjust their methods for cold conditions, like by using specialized adhesives and planning work around suitable temperature windows.

Myth #7: You can’t replace an entire system during winter

While complete roof replacements used to be impractical or even impossible during winter, that’s not exactly the case today. When conditions allow, experienced crews can work year-round. For installation to go smoothly, however, clear and dry weather with moderate temperatures is still essential. 

Contractors often take on full replacements during the off-season, especially for urgent issues, like when the existing system has failed or moisture threatens structural integrity. While asphalt shingles and adhesives react differently to cold weather, skilled professionals know how to manage these challenges and deliver results just as reliable as in any other season.

Who are the best and most reliable roofing contractors in Damariscotta?

At Horch Roofing, precision and reliability come standard. Our team combines decades of regional experience with materials built to endure Maine’s toughest winters. From asphalt shingles and standing-seam metal to EPDM rubber and seamless gutters, every installation is carefully designed for long-term protection and efficiency. We also provide prompt repair and dispatch services to keep your home safe through snow, ice, and sudden thaws.

Whether you’re near Whaleback Shell Midden State Historic Site or elsewhere in Damariscotta, you can count on solutions that last. Ready to safeguard your home before the next freeze? Contact us today for your consultation.